NEW

Overtime Tracker Tools Compared: Which Ones Warn You Before Overtime and Which Only Count It After

Track overtime against each schedule with actiTIME
November 2026
Overtime Tracker Tools Compared: Which Ones Warn You Before Overtime and Which Only Count It After

An overtime tracker records the hours each person works beyond their schedule or the legal threshold, applies the overtime rule that fits them, and passes the result on to payroll or to your cost reports. Every tool in this category counts overtime. The real differences show up earlier and later: whether the tool warns a manager before someone crosses the line, whether it can apply a daily rule as well as a weekly one, and where the overtime hours land once they are approved.

This guide compares 7 overtime trackers on those points. Each claim about a tool comes from the vendor’s own pricing page or help documentation, and where a vendor does not document something, the tables say so instead of guessing.

Short answer:
For hourly shift teams that need a warning before overtime starts, Buddy Punch, QuickBooks Time and Homebase all send overtime alerts. If you need many rule types for free, Jibble applies daily, weekly, rest day and public holiday overtime on every version. If your overtime has to be costed against clients and projects, actiTIME puts overtime hours and overtime cost into the same reports as project time and billing.

What an overtime tracker has to do

Judge any overtime management software on four jobs. A tool that only records hours covers half of the first one.

  • Apply the right rule. A weekly threshold, a daily threshold, double time, rest days and public holidays, set per person or per group, because salaried staff who are not entitled to overtime should not show any.
  • Warn before overtime happens. An alert to the manager when someone is close to the threshold is the only feature that reduces overtime instead of reporting it.
  • Approve and lock. Overtime that was approved should not change after payroll has run, so look for timesheet approval and locking.
  • Hand the hours on. To payroll as an export or an integration, and, if you bill clients or run projects, to cost reports that show which work the overtime went into.

Which overtime rule your tracker has to apply

The rule depends on where your people work, so check the settings against the law that applies to each group. Four common cases:

  • United States, federal. Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, covered nonexempt employees get at least one and a half times their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek, and hours cannot be averaged across weeks (DOL Fact Sheet 23).
  • California. Overtime also starts after 8 hours in a workday, double time after 12 hours in a day, and special rules apply to the seventh consecutive day of work (California Labor Commissioner). Our California overtime laws guide goes deeper on the state rules.
  • European Union. The Working Time Directive caps average working time at 48 hours per seven days, overtime included, over a reference period of up to four months. Pay rates for overtime are set nationally.
  • United Kingdom. The 48 hour average is normally calculated over 17 weeks, and workers can opt out of the 48 hour week, so your tracker needs to show who opted out and who did not.

For the arithmetic behind overtime pay, including regular rate adjustments and salaried staff, see our overtime calculation guide. For the process side of recording overtime and the new qualified overtime reporting in the US, read the overtime tracking guide.

Worked example: the same 40 hours, two overtime answers

The rule setting decides more than the timer does. Take an hourly employee in California earns $28 an hour (illustrative) and works 10, 10, 10, 6 and 4 hours from Monday to Friday. That is exactly 40 hours. An overtime tracker set to a weekly rule only reports zero overtime. A tracker that also applies the California daily rule finds 6 hours.

Weekly hours: 10 + 10 + 10 + 6 + 4 = 40 h
Weekly rule only (over 40 h): 0 h of overtime, pay 40 h x $28 = $1,120
Daily rule (over 8 h in a day): 2 + 2 + 2 = 6 h of overtime
Regular pay with the daily rule: 34 h x $28 = $952
Overtime pay at one and a half times: 6 h x $42 = $252
Correct weekly pay: $952 + $252 = $1,204
Underpayment with the wrong rule: $1,204 − $1,120 = $84 per week

The gap is the overtime premium: half the hourly rate, $14, on each of the 6 daily overtime hours. Across 10 employees with the same pattern for 26 weeks, that adds up to $21,840 of unpaid premium. Each extra hour past 8 in a day adds another $14 at this rate, and every $1 rise in the hourly rate adds $0.50 per overtime hour. Before you compare features, check that the tool can apply both a daily and a weekly threshold to the same person, because some can do only one at a time.

Overtime tracking software compared

The first table covers the rules each overtime tracking software can apply and whether it warns anyone before overtime starts. “Not documented” means the vendor pages we read do not describe the feature, not that it is missing.

Tool Overtime rules you can set Warning before overtime
actiTIME Per user mode: disabled, automatic (hidden or shown in the timesheet) or manual entry; overtime measured against each person’s schedule; separate overtime rate per user No pre-overtime alert documented; overtime shows in the timesheet and in the Time Balance and Overtime Report
Clockify One calculation period per workspace (daily, weekly or monthly) against each user’s daily capacity Not documented for overtime
Jibble Daily, daily double, weekly, rest day and public holiday rules with thresholds and multipliers; weekly cannot be combined with the daily types Not documented in the overtime help article
Buddy Punch Automatic calculation, with federal and state overtime tracked separately Yes: daily or weekly alerts by email or push, a set number of hours before the threshold
QuickBooks Time Daily, weekly and time of day overtime with custom multipliers Yes: one daily and one weekly alert per person, managed by admins
Homebase Rules for over 40 hours a week or over 8 hours a day Yes: alerts before employees reach overtime, plus blocking of early clock ins
Deputy Pay Rate Builder with daily and periodic overtime, multiplier or flat rate, reset per day or per shift Not documented in the pay rule articles we read

The second table follows each overtime tracker past the timesheet, showing who signs the hours off and where the overtime ends up.

Tool Approval and locking Where overtime ends up
actiTIME Time-Track Approval; Lock Time-Track after approval, invoicing or period close Time Balance and Overtime Report, Cost of Work Report and Profit/Loss Report; export as HTML, CSV or PDF
Clockify Approval and timesheet locking on the Standard tier Attendance report; overtime can be converted to time off; QuickBooks integration on Standard, labor cost on Pro
Jibble Managers approve timesheets per pay period; past logs are locked Payroll hours with an overtime breakdown; Excel or CSV export; QuickBooks Online, Deel and Xero integrations
Buddy Punch Time card approval workflow before payroll Payroll integrations; CSV, Excel or PDF export
QuickBooks Time Timesheet approvals Overtime settings live in QuickBooks Online, so hours stay inside the QuickBooks payroll setup
Homebase Missed punches flagged on timesheets before payroll; automatic clock out Homebase payroll applies regular and overtime wages; records kept for up to 6 years
Deputy Timesheet Auto Approval on the Core tier Payroll and HR integrations from the Lite tier

7 overtime trackers

1. actiTIME

  • Overtime modes
  • Overtime rate
  • Cost of work
  • Approval and locking

actiTIME is project time tracking software built for billing, and that shapes how it handles overtime. People log hours against customers, projects and tasks in a weekly timesheet, a calendar or the iOS and Android app, and with Overtime Registration turned on, actiTIME compares those hours with each person’s schedule.

Each user gets one of four overtime modes, set individually or inherited from corporate settings: disabled for staff who are not entitled to overtime, automatic and hidden from the user, automatic and visible in their timesheet, or entered manually. Overtime is paid at a separate overtime rate in the user’s profile. The Time Balance and Overtime Report shows worked time against scheduled hours for the whole team, and the Cost of Work Report shows overtime hours at regular rates inside each customer and project, plus the overtime premium as a separate general cost line for the period, so you see both where the extra hours went and what the premium added. Time-Track Approval and Lock Time-Track keep approved weeks from changing, and leave types with PTO balances sit in the same account.

Where it falls short for shift work: the product documentation describes no alert before someone reaches overtime, and each user has one overtime rate, so double time needs a manual adjustment. actiTIME does not run payroll either; payroll gets the hours as a CSV export. Overtime Registration is not part of the free version.

Pricing: free for up to 3 users without overtime features; online from $5 per user per month, with a full featured 30 day trial. See actiTIME pricing.

We reduced payroll processing to 45 minutes per week

actiTIME is very robust, integrated well into your business process, and most important, helps you focus on your business instead of monkeying around with technology. actiTIME has reduced our payroll processing from 4-6 hours per week to 45 minutes per week.

2. Clockify

  • Attendance report
  • Overtime to time off
  • Timesheet locking
  • Free for 5 users

Clockify is a general time tracker that many teams already use for projects, which makes it an easy place to start tracking overtime. Overtime lives in the attendance report. You set each user’s daily work capacity, then pick one overtime calculation period for the workspace: daily, weekly or monthly. With the weekly setting, capacity is multiplied by the working days in the week, and anything above that total counts as overtime, anything below as undertime.

A useful extra is time off in lieu. Clockify can convert overtime into a time off balance, calculated from the same period setting, which suits companies that bank extra hours instead of paying them out. Approval and timesheet locking come with the same tier as overtime, and labor cost and profit reporting start one tier higher.

What holds it back is the rule itself. The help documentation describes overtime as hours above capacity for one period per workspace, with no daily and weekly combination and no multiplier settings, so the example above would need manual checking. Overtime is also not part of the free version.

Pricing: free for up to 5 users; Standard, which includes attendance and overtime, is $5.49 per seat per month billed annually or $6.99 monthly.

3. Jibble

  • Five overtime types
  • Multipliers
  • Pay period approval
  • Free version

Jibble is a time and attendance app built around clocking in and out, and it has the widest set of overtime rules available at no cost. Inside a work schedule you can define daily overtime, daily double overtime, weekly overtime, rest day overtime and public holiday overtime, each with its own threshold and multiplier, and choose whether overtime starts after a number of hours or at a time of day. Multipliers apply to each member’s rate, for example 2x for work on a rest day.

Overtime shows in daily, weekly and monthly timesheets, marked with a moon icon, and in a payroll view that breaks out overtime hours. Managers approve timesheets for each pay period, and approved logs are locked. Exports go to Excel or CSV, and integrations send hours to QuickBooks Online, Deel or Xero.

The catch is in Jibble’s own help article: weekly overtime cannot be combined with daily, double daily, rest day or public holiday overtime in a schedule. Where a law needs both a daily and a weekly threshold, as in California, that setup needs a workaround. The overtime article also does not describe an alert before overtime starts.

Pricing: free for unlimited users, and the help center says owners and admins can set overtime rules on all versions.

4. Buddy Punch

  • Overtime alerts
  • Federal and state overtime
  • Payroll sync
  • Geofencing

Buddy Punch is a time clock for hourly teams, and it is one of three tools here with a documented alert that fires before overtime starts. Its overtime alert runs on a daily or weekly interval and fires a chosen number of hours or minutes before the threshold, by email, push notification or both. Alerts can go to administrators, managers or the employee, you can create as many as you need, and one person can sit under several alerts.

Overtime is calculated automatically, with federal and state overtime tracked separately, which helps when part of a team works under a daily state rule. Time cards go through an approval workflow before payroll, and approved hours sync to payroll providers or export as CSV, Excel or PDF. Scheduling is included from the middle tier, as is geofencing that limits punches to approved locations.

One documented limit: the overtime alert only triggers on punches with a start and end time, so hours entered as a duration slip past it. The $19 base fee also weighs more on a team of three or four than on a team of forty.

Pricing: Starter $4.99 per user per month billed annually or $5.99 monthly, Pro $6.99 or $7.99, Advanced $12.99 or $13.99, each plus a $19 monthly base fee.

5. QuickBooks Time

  • Custom multipliers
  • Overtime alerts
  • Payroll sync
  • Scheduling

QuickBooks Time fits companies that already run payroll in QuickBooks Online, which is where its overtime settings are configured. Those settings accept daily, weekly and time of day rules, each with its own multiplier. Intuit’s help article on custom overtime shows a daily rule at 1.5 times base pay after 8 hours next to a weekly rule after 40 hours, which is the combination a California employer needs.

Overtime alerts warn before the threshold. Only admins can manage them, and each person can have one daily and one weekly alert, which covers most cases but leaves no room for a second, earlier warning. Scheduling is included in every tier, so managers can see overtime coming in the schedule as well as in the alerts.

The price is the drawback. You pay a base fee plus a per user price that is higher than most tools here, and much of the value depends on already using QuickBooks.

Pricing: Time Premium $20 per month plus $10 per user per month; Time Elite $40 per month plus $12 per user per month, with an introductory discount for the first 3 months.

6. Homebase

  • Overtime alerts
  • Early clock in blocking
  • Payroll
  • Per location pricing

Homebase combines scheduling, a time clock and an overtime tracker app for restaurants, shops and other single or multi location businesses with hourly staff. Its overtime features are built around prevention. You set overtime rules for more than 40 hours a week or more than 8 hours a day, managers get alerts before an employee reaches overtime, and the time clock can block clock ins before a scheduled shift opens or for shifts that were never scheduled.

Missed clock outs trigger a reminder and an automatic clock out, and they are flagged on the timesheet before payroll. If you use Homebase payroll, regular and overtime wages are applied from the timesheets, including for staff who work at more than one location at different rates. Homebase says it keeps digital records for up to 6 years.

Two things to check. Pricing is per location, so a business with many small sites pays for each one, and the pricing page does not say which tier includes overtime rules and alerts, so confirm that in a trial. There is no project or client costing.

Pricing: Basic free for up to 10 employees at one location; Essentials $30, Plus $70 and All in one $120 per location per month.

7. Deputy

  • Pay Rate Builder
  • Daily overtime
  • Shift scheduling
  • Payroll integrations

Deputy is shift scheduling and timesheet software for larger hourly workforces, and its overtime handling is the most configurable on this list. The Pay Rate Builder lets you start from preset pay rates or build your own. A daily overtime rule triggers after a set number of hours across all shifts in a workday, ignores unpaid breaks, pays a multiplier of the base rate or a flat rate, can be limited to part of the day such as a night window, and can reset per day or per shift when someone works two shifts. Periodic overtime handles longer periods.

That depth suits multi location operators with award rates, union agreements or night premiums. Timesheet Auto Approval comes with the Core tier, and payroll and HR integrations start on Lite.

Expect to spend time on setup. Deputy’s help center suggests touching some advanced fields, such as rate tags, only on an implementation consultant’s advice, and the pay rule articles we read do not describe an alert before overtime. Monthly billing also carries a minimum spend of $30 per invoice.

Pricing: Lite $5, Core $6.50 and Pro $9 per user per month in USD, with a 10% saving on annual billing.

Best pick by situation

Match the overtime tracker to the problem you run into most often.

  • You bill clients or run projects and need to see where overtime hours go: actiTIME, because overtime hours show up by customer and project in the Cost of Work Report, with the overtime premium reported as one general cost for the period.
  • You want to stop overtime before it happens: Buddy Punch, which allows unlimited alerts timed a set number of hours before the threshold.
  • Your payroll runs in QuickBooks and you have staff in California: QuickBooks Time, which combines daily and weekly rules with multipliers.
  • You need many overtime types and have no budget: Jibble, as long as you do not need weekly and daily rules in the same schedule.
  • You run one shop or restaurant with up to 10 staff: Homebase, which blocks early clock ins and warns before overtime.
  • You have shift premiums, night rates or several locations: Deputy, if you can give its pay rules proper setup time.
  • Your team already tracks project time and mainly wants to bank overtime as time off: Clockify, which converts overtime to a time off balance.

Where overtime tracking breaks

Most problems with an overtime management system come from how it is set up and used. Check for these in the first few pay periods.

  • One rule for everyone. A weekly threshold applied to a team that includes California staff underpays them, as the worked example shows. Map each group to its rule before you switch the tracker on.
  • Overtime switched on for exempt staff. Salaried employees who are not entitled to overtime then show balances that confuse payroll. Disable overtime for them so all their hours count as regular time.
  • “Not approved” treated as “not paid”. Under the FLSA, announcing that unapproved overtime will not be paid does not remove the duty to pay for overtime that was worked (DOL Fact Sheet 23). Use approval to manage overtime, never to delete it.
  • Edits after payroll. If approved timesheets stay editable, an employee or manager can change last month’s hours after the pay run. Lock approved periods.
  • Duration entries that dodge the alert. Some alerts only watch clock in and clock out times, so hours typed in afterwards never trigger them. Decide whether people punch or enter durations, and set alerts to match.
  • Overtime that nobody traces to its cause. Paying overtime correctly does not make it go away. If the same project or client produces most of it every month, the fix is in estimates and staffing, which our guide on how to reduce overtime covers.

Track overtime against each person’s schedule and see which clients and projects the extra hours went to with actiTIME

Try Free

Overtime tracker

FAQ

Is there a free overtime tracker?

Yes. Jibble is free for unlimited users and lets you set daily, weekly, rest day and public holiday overtime rules on every version. Homebase is free for up to 10 employees at one location. Clockify and actiTIME have free versions too, but overtime is a paid feature in both.

How do I find my overtime hours?

Compare the hours you worked with the threshold that applies to you, per workweek and, where the law requires it, per day. In a tracker, that comparison is a report: in actiTIME, the Time Balance and Overtime Report shows worked time against scheduled hours for any date range. Keep your own daily record of start and end times if you want to check your pay independently.

How do I calculate overtime pay?

Multiply the overtime hours by the overtime rate, which in the US is at least one and a half times the regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek, and add regular pay for the remaining hours. The regular rate can include bonuses and shift differentials, so it is not always the base hourly wage. Our overtime calculation guide works through salaried, hourly and day rate cases, and the overtime calculator does the math for you.

To see overtime next to project hours and costs, start a free trial of actiTIME with full features, Overtime Registration included, for 30 days. After the trial, teams of up to 3 users can keep using the free version.

Are you ready to drive your business growth with actiTIME?

Start Using actiTIME